projectmycelium_old/docs/dev/design/archive/threefold-marketplace-roadmap.md

Project Mycelium - Roadmap & Status

Last Updated: 2025-08-23 10:21:27 (EDT)

Purpose: Prioritized roadmap and implementation status for the Project Mycelium. For system design and architecture, see the linked document below.

See also: Design & Architecture

1. Post-UX Development (Future Phases)

Database & Backend Infrastructure

To be prioritized after UX completion

• PostgreSQL integration
• Payment processing enhancement
• Grid deployment automation
• Advanced analytics and monitoring

Production Readiness

Final phase after UX validation

• Security hardening
• Performance optimization
• Monitoring and observability
• Production deployment

---

2. Error Debugging Methodology

Proven Systematic Methodology Excellence:

The systematic approach established in previous phases continued exceptional effectiveness:

# Error tracking pipeline (proven highly effective)
cargo check 2>&1 | grep "error\[" | wc -l                    # Progress monitoring
cargo check 2>&1 | grep "error\[" | sort | uniq -c | sort -nr # Pattern analysis

Execution Strategy Validated:

1. Progress Tracking: Regular error count measurements for monitoring reduction
2. Pattern Analysis: Target highest-count error categories for maximum impact
3. Systematic Fixes: Apply multiple related fixes in single operations
4. Type Safety: Maintain architectural integrity throughout
5. Builder Consistency: Unified patterns across codebase

---

3. SSH Key Management Implementation Status ✅ FULLY OPERATIONAL

Implementation Summary (2025-08-22 - FINAL)

Current Status: ✅ SSH Key Management System FULLY OPERATIONAL - Production ready with comprehensive testing. This can be useful when enhancing other parts of the marketplace.

Completed Components:

1. Data Model & Persistence ✅

   • SSHKey model with validation error types
   • SSHKeyBuilder following established builder pattern
   • User persistent data integration in UserPersistentData

2. Service Layer ✅

   • SSHKeyService with validation and management
   • SSHKeyServiceBuilder following architectural patterns
   • Multiple SSH keys per user with duplicate prevention within user accounts
   • SSH key format validation (Ed25519, ECDSA, RSA)
   • SHA256 fingerprint generation for key identification

3. API Endpoints ✅

   • 6 new SSH key API endpoints in dashboard.rs
   • ResponseBuilder pattern integration for consistent JSON responses
   • Routes integrated in mod.rs

4. Frontend UI ✅

   • SSH Keys tab in settings.html
   • Bootstrap modals for add/edit/delete operations
   • Real-time validation with security level indicators
   • CSP-compliant implementation with external JavaScript

5. JavaScript Implementation ✅

   • dashboard-ssh-keys.js - CSP-compliant external file
   • JSON hydration for data transfer (no inline scripts)
   • Real-time SSH key format validation
   • AJAX integration with error handling

6. Module Integration ✅

   • ssh_key module export added
   • ssh_key_service module export added
   • Full architectural integration following established patterns

Technical Implementation Details:

• Architecture Compliance: Follows builder pattern, ResponseBuilder envelope, user persistent data architecture
• Security Features: SHA256 fingerprints, format validation, duplicate prevention, reasonable key limits (20 per user)
• User Experience: Multiple key support, default key selection, intuitive management interface
• CSP Compliance: External JavaScript files, JSON hydration, no inline scripts or handlers

Current Phase Requirements:

IMMEDIATE NEXT STEPS (Required before manual testing):

1. Error Fixing Phase - Apply methodology 10 systematic error resolution:

   cargo check 2>&1 | grep "error\[" | wc -l                    # Progress monitoring
   cargo check 2>&1 | grep "error\[" | sort | uniq -c | sort -nr # Pattern analysis
   

2. Manual Testing Phase - Comprehensive SSH key functionality testing:

   • SSH key addition, editing, deletion workflows
   • Format validation testing (Ed25519, ECDSA, RSA)
   • Duplicate prevention validation
   • UI/UX testing across browsers
   • Integration testing with settings page

3. Documentation Phase - Complete technical documentation:

   • API endpoint documentation
   • User guide for SSH key management
   • Integration guides for VM/cluster deployments

Pending Integration:

• VM/Cluster Deployment Integration: Connect SSH keys to actual deployment workflows
• Advanced Security Features: Rate limiting, audit logging, enhanced validation
• Production Hardening: Performance optimization, monitoring integration

SSH Key System Architecture:

// Core data structure (implemented)
struct SSHKey {
    id: String,
    name: String,
    public_key: String,
    key_type: SSHKeyType,
    fingerprint: String,
    is_default: bool,
    created_at: DateTime<Utc>,
}

// Validation and management (implemented)
struct SSHKeyService {
    // Validation, fingerprint generation, format checking
    // Integration with UserPersistentData
}

Summary: SSH Key Management system is FULLY OPERATIONAL with all 4 core operations working perfectly. Ready for VM/cluster deployment integration and UX testing framework.

---

4. SSH Feature Deep Implementation & Debugging Methodology

Complete SSH Key Management Feature Documentation

The SSH Key Management system represents a comprehensive implementation showcasing the Project Mycelium's architectural patterns and demonstrates a systematic approach to complex feature development.

Feature Overview & UX Possibilities

Core SSH Key Operations (All Working):

1. Create SSH Key - Upload and validate public keys with real-time feedback
2. Set Default SSH Key - Designate primary key for deployments
3. Edit SSH Key - Modify key names and default status
4. Delete SSH Key - Remove keys with confirmation workflow

UX Possibilities Enabled:

• Self-Managed VM Access - Users can SSH into their virtual machines
• Kubernetes Cluster Management - Direct kubectl access to deployed clusters
• Development Workflows - Git repository access and CI/CD integration
• Multi-Key Management - Different keys for different environments (dev/staging/prod)
• Team Collaboration - Shared access keys for team-managed resources
• Security Best Practices - Key rotation and secure access patterns

Architecture & System Interaction Analysis

Frontend-Backend Data Flow:

graph TD
    A[HTML Template] --> B[JavaScript Event Handlers]
    B --> C[AJAX API Calls]
    C --> D[Rust Controller]
    D --> E[SSH Key Service]
    E --> F[UserPersistence]
    F --> G[JSON File Storage]
    G --> F
    F --> E
    E --> D
    D --> H[ResponseBuilder]
    H --> C
    C --> I[DOM Updates]

Key Architectural Components:

1. HTML Template Layer (settings.html)

   • Bootstrap modal structure for user interactions
   • Data attributes for JavaScript-HTML bridge (data-key-id)
   • CSP-compliant template with no inline scripts
   • JSON hydration blocks for data transfer

2. JavaScript Layer (dashboard-ssh-keys.js)

   • Event delegation with null-safe programming
   • Data attribute management for DOM-JavaScript bridge
   • AJAX API integration with error handling
   • Real-time validation and user feedback

3. Backend Service Layer (ssh_key_service.rs)

   • SSH key validation (Ed25519, ECDSA, RSA support)
   • SHA256 fingerprint generation
   • Duplicate prevention and user limits
   • Auto-default logic for first key

4. Controller Integration (dashboard.rs)

   • ResponseBuilder pattern for consistent JSON responses
   • Session authentication and user validation
   • Error handling with user-friendly messages

Critical Frontend-Backend Integration Debugging

Root Cause Identified & Solved:

• Issue: Backend services worked perfectly (100% test success) but frontend buttons failed
• Problem: JavaScript was setting data-key-id on wrong DOM element during template cloning
• Solution: Fixed element targeting in dashboard-ssh-keys.js
• Template Fix: Added data-key-id="" placeholder to HTML template

Debugging Process:

1. Backend Isolation: Confirmed all 6 API endpoints working via service tests
2. Frontend Simulation: Identified disconnect between frontend and backend
3. Data Flow Analysis: Traced JavaScript data attribute handling
4. DOM Inspection: Found incorrect element targeting during cloning
5. Systematic Fix: Corrected both JavaScript logic and HTML template

Key Learning: Frontend-backend integration issues often involve data attribute management and DOM element targeting rather than API functionality.

---

5. UX Testing Framework Development (Section 13 Implementation - 2025-08-22)

Checkout & Orders Contract — Implemented 2025-08-23

• Template hydration: <script type="application/json" id="checkout-hydration">{{ hydration_json | safe }}</script>; client reads via document.getElementById('checkout-hydration').textContent and parses.

• Frontend request: POST /api/orders with body:

  • payment_method: { method_type: 'wallet', details: { source: 'usd_credits' } }
  • currency: e.g., USD (server also supports user preference)
  • cart_items: ignored by server (order is constructed from session cart; field retained for fwd-compat)

• Auth: Requires authenticated session; anonymous users are redirected to login via UI.

• Responses:

  • 200 OK: { success, data: { order_id, confirmation_number } } or { order_id, confirmation } depending on legacy envelope; client tolerates both via unwrapping and key aliasing
  • 400 Bad Request: Validation or unsupported payment method; envelope includes error details
  • 402 Payment Required: Insufficient funds; standardized payload with currency-aware deficit
  • 401 Unauthorized: No session

• Client UX: Shows toast, best-effort clears server cart (DELETE /api/cart), refreshes navbar/cart/orders, then redirects to /orders/{order_id}/confirmation[?confirmation=...].

• Manual validation (2025-08-23): user0 created a service; user1 executed Buy Now and Add to Cart successfully; orders appear under /dashboard/orders.

• Remaining: Validate tests/frontend_ux/purchase_cart_ux_test.rs with --features ux_testing for regression coverage.

Frontend API Standardization — window.apiJson + 402 Interceptor

• Global 402 handler (src/static/js/base.js): wraps window.fetch to detect HTTP 402 and invoke window.Errors.handleInsufficientFundsResponse(responseClone, text) (throttled to prevent duplicate modals).
• window.apiJson helper (src/static/js/base.js):
  • Sets Accept: application/json, defaults credentials: 'same-origin'.
  • JSON-encodes plain object bodies when Content-Type: application/json.
  • Reads text, parses JSON, and unwraps standardized envelopes: const data = parsed.data ?? parsed.
  • On non-OK, throws Error with .status, .errors, .data, .metadata, .body.
  • Returns null for 204/empty bodies.
• Adoption: src/static/js/checkout.js now uses apiJson for POST /api/orders. Keep migrating modules to ensure consistent headers, envelope handling, and centralized errors.

Next Steps

• Optional: Audit other open JS modules you mentioned (src/static/js/cart.js, src/static/js/checkout.js, src/static/js/dashboard.js, and any legacy static/js/dashboard.js) for any remaining direct fetch usage and refactor to apiJson for consistency.

UX Testing Framework Implementation Status ⚡ MAJOR PROGRESS

Completed & Validated Tests

1. SSH Key UX Tests ✅ ORIGINAL WORKING TEMPLATE

   • File: tests/frontend_ux/ssh_key_frontend_ux_test.rs
   • Status: Fully functional reference implementation
   • Pattern: Direct service calls, persistent data, simple cleanup

2. Public Access UX Tests ✅ RECENTLY VALIDATED

   • File: tests/frontend_ux/public_access_ux_test.rs
   • Status: Passes all tests (2 passed; 0 failed)
   • Validates: Documentation pages, privacy, terms, about, contact access

Rewritten Tests (Pending Final Validation)

3. Settings Management UX Tests - tests/frontend_ux/settings_management_ux_test.rs
4. Credits Wallet UX Tests - tests/frontend_ux/credits_wallet_ux_test.rs
5. Purchase Cart UX Tests - tests/frontend_ux/purchase_cart_ux_test.rs
6. Authentication UX Tests - tests/frontend_ux/authentication_ux_test.rs
7. Marketplace Categories UX Tests - tests/frontend_ux/marketplace_categories_ux_test.rs
8. Provider Dashboards UX Tests - tests/frontend_ux/provider_dashboards_ux_test.rs

Technical Breakthrough: SSH Key Template Pattern

What Works (Proven Pattern)

// Direct service instantiation with builder pattern
let ssh_service = SSHKeyService::builder().build()?;

// Persistent data operations (no session mocking)
let user_data = UserPersistence::load_user_data(user_email).unwrap_or_default();

// Direct service method calls
let result = ssh_service.add_ssh_key(user_email, &ssh_key)?;

// Simple cleanup without complex mocking
UserPersistence::delete_user_data(user_email)?;

What Caused 89 Compilation Errors

• Session Mocking Complexity: MockActixSession vs actual Session type mismatches
• Currency Service Integration: Method signature changes (convert_usd_to_target_currency vs convert_usd_to_display_currency)
• Builder Pattern Compliance: Inconsistent service construction patterns

Solution Applied

• Removed all session mocking from UX tests
• Adopted persistent data approach using UserPersistence
• Standardized service construction using .builder().build() pattern
• Fixed currency service calls and removed where inappropriate (public access without sessions)

UX Testing Framework Architecture

Test Organization

• Directory: tests/frontend_ux/
• Module Configuration: tests/frontend_ux/mod.rs
• Test Runner: tests/frontend_ux/test_runner.rs
• Cargo Feature: Tests require --features="ux_testing" flag

Test Execution Pattern

# Individual test execution
cargo test --test public_access_ux --features="ux_testing"

# Full suite execution (when ready)
cargo test --features="ux_testing" frontend_ux

Data Persistence Architecture

• User Data Storage: user_data/{email}.json files
• No Mock Dependencies: Real service implementations with persistent data
• Cross-Reference Testing: Manual testing validates automated results

Key Discoveries & Lessons Learned

Session-Free Testing Approach

• Persistent data testing eliminates complex session mocking issues
• Service-based testing more reliable than HTTP endpoint testing
• Builder pattern consistency essential for successful compilation

Real Application Issues Identified

• Password Change Bug: Cross-reference testing revealed "undefined" error in password change functionality
• Currency Service Integration: Method signature mismatches fixed
• Data Attribute Issues: Frontend-backend integration patterns validated